Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Small Casserole
Hamburger Pie Casserole
Ham and Potatoes Au Gratin Casserole
Hanky Pankies
About
Yesteryears Homemade Casseroles
Welcome to the charming world of Yesteryears Homemade Casseroles, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Prattville, Alabama. Located at 146 W Main St A, this quaint establishment is more than just a restaurant—it's a celebration of nostalgia and comfort food, packaged with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. When you step inside, you are immediately enveloped by the essence of homemade meals, crafted with love and care.
Customers rave about the casseroles, often declaring them the best they've ever tasted. A perfect solution for busy families, these dishes can simply be taken home and warmed in the oven, and are consistently rated *husband and kid-approved*! If you're looking for a satisfying meal that feels like a warm hug after a long day, you're in the right place.
But the culinary delights don't stop with casseroles. From the pimento cheese sandwiches that one loyal patron describes as the best in the world to the creamy and flavorful chicken salad, Yesteryears is a treasure trove of comfort foods. Each dish is prepared with high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite is as good as it gets.
Connie, the heart and soul behind Yesteryears, is not just the owner but a passionate advocate for local, homemade food. Her friendly demeanor and personal touch shine through in every interaction, making each visit feel like a homecoming. Customers have shared sentiments of warmth and community, appreciating the cozy small-town feel that makes each visit special.
The atmosphere here is a true reflection of its service: inviting, friendly, and filled with the intoxicating aroma of home-cooked meals. Whether you're in for a quick bite or to browse unique items that are always available, Yesteryears Homemade Casseroles offers an experience that goes beyond just food—it's about community and connection.
With high praises floating around, such as “the best pimento cheese spread” or “delicious chicken salad,” it's evident why many find this spot hard to resist. If you find yourself in Prattville, make sure to stop by Yesteryears. Your taste buds will thank you, and your heart will be full.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ OMG! The pimento cheese spread is to die for! I love the mixture with the pecans! Cost about the same as going to Chicken Salad Chick, but with a few more options. Small town, cozy feel & great food. ”
“ This is my "go to" place in Prattville! I visit once a year and never miss lunch (best pimento cheese sandwiches in the world) and shopping (always something new and pretty). Super friendly atmosphere and employees. Love ya! ”
“ Miss Connie's Casseroles are the best. Not to mention the other goodies she sells. I always try to keep one or two in the freezer at all times. Marla's Poppyseed Chicken Casserole is our favorite. And the cabbage soup. ”
“ They have the BEST casseroles ever! Just take home and warm in the oven. Husband/kid-approved!! Also, they have the BEST chicken salad! ”
“ I love the atmosphere, the kindness of the people that work there...My go to is for the chicken salad & pimento cheese they are so delicious.. ”
“ Best place in downtown Prattville!!! They've got AMAZING pre-cooked dinners/casseroles that are so easy for quick dinners. And the BEST chicken salad ever!!! ... The boutique and antique shop inside have cute and unique items, highly recommend this place to anyone!! ”
“ I don’t get a chance to get to Prattville that often, but when I do, I make sure to stop by here to purchase some casseroles and soups. Connie, the owner, is a real sweetheart and very much involved in her business, always there to greet with you with a smile and help you out. I think it’s so important to support your local mom and pop stores, while benefiting from food that is lovingly home made. You can’t go wrong! ”